A Data Center Digest Original StoryThis article was researched and written entirely by AI, without human review or editing, as part of the Data Center Digest's ongoing experiment in AI-powered journalism.

When states have audited their data center tax breaks, the auditors have reached the same result on revenue: the breaks do not pay for themselves in state taxes. Virginia's legislative auditors estimated in November 2026 that the state's sales tax exemption for data centers brought back 22 cents in state revenue for every dollar it cost from fiscal 2021 through 2025. A December 2025 evaluation for Georgia found the state's exemption produced a net revenue loss in every year it studied.

Whether the promised jobs showed up is harder to say. Most states count the jobs companies commit to, or the jobs an economic model estimates, rather than jobs anyone has checked. Where official figures exist, the cost per job ranges from about $34,000 to roughly $900,000, depending on what is counted. Most of the work is construction, which ends when the buildings are finished.

This article draws on reports from Virginia's Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission (JLARC), Georgia's Department of Audits and Accounts, Washington's legislative auditor, and the Illinois Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity (DCEO). It also uses testimony from the Texas Comptroller's office, given as Texas lawmakers prepare to take up a bill that would repeal that state's exemption.

How the breaks work and who checks them

The largest state data center incentives are sales and use tax exemptions. A use tax is the companion tax owed on taxable goods bought without paying sales tax, for example from out of state. The exemptions cover servers, networking gear, cooling systems and generators. Texas also exempts the electricity the facilities use.

In return, companies must invest a minimum amount and create jobs. In 2019, JLARC described Virginia's terms as a $150 million investment and 50 new jobs paying at least 1.5 times the local average wage, or 25 jobs in high-unemployment areas. Texas requires 20 jobs at 120 percent of the county median wage and $200 million invested over five years, or 40 jobs and $500 million for the largest projects. Illinois requires $250 million, 20 jobs at 120 percent of the county average wage, and a project labor agreement, which is a pre-hire contract with construction unions. Georgia requires 25 jobs and $250 million in counties with more than 50,000 people, and as few as five jobs and $25 million in counties with fewer than 30,000.

Local property tax breaks are a separate layer, negotiated county by county. John Diamond of Rice University's Baker Institute told CBS Austin that under one Milam County, Texas, agreement, the developer would pay 25 percent of its would-be property taxes over a 10-year abatement period. None of the state evaluations reviewed here measures these local breaks.

Each evaluation depends on a "but for" assumption: an estimate of how much of the investment happened only because of the tax break. A Good Jobs First report, as summarized by DatacenterDynamics, found that 12 of the 32 states with data center subsidy programs do not disclose how much revenue they give up. In Texas, the Comptroller's office turned down a Texas Tribune records request for facility-level data, citing state confidentiality law.

Virginia's three verdicts

Virginia has the longest record, and its verdict has grown less favorable with each report. JLARC's 2019 study covered fiscal 2010 through 2017, when the exemption cost an average of $52.2 million a year.

The November 2026 report found 22 cents and 29 jobs per $1 million for fiscal 2021 through 2025, when the exemption averaged $811.5 million a year and reached an estimated $1.4 billion in fiscal 2025. That made it 60 percent of everything Virginia spent on economic development incentives from fiscal 2016 to 2025. That figure includes supplier and spending-driven jobs and subtracts jobs lost to the taxes needed to cover the exemption's cost.

Ellen Miller, JLARC's chief economic development analyst, told lawmakers that power availability and community acceptance may now weigh more than the tax break in companies' location decisions.

This article uses the 2026 figures.

The state figures leave out local revenue, which is where the fiscal case is strongest. Loudoun has separately reported $1.2 billion in data center real and personal property tax revenue, 39 percent of its budget, according to the Virginia Mercury. The 2026 budget kept the exemption and added an energy consumption tax on data centers.

Georgia, Washington, Illinois and Texas

Georgia's December 2025 evaluation was prepared by the University of Georgia's Carl Vinson Institute of Government under the Tax Expenditures Transparency Act of 2024 (Senate Bill 366). It cut the share of data center construction attributed to the exemption from the 90 percent assumed in a 2022 study to 30 percent. The new figure came from a statistical model built on data for 34 Georgia data centers and on national facility data. The evaluation estimated $450.6 million in forgone state revenue in 2024 and a net loss of $416.6 million after counting the new taxes data centers generate. It projects a net loss of $780.2 million in 2030. The same report also calculated a return of $2.86 in added economic output (value added, roughly the contribution to state GDP) for each dollar of forgone revenue. The researchers cautioned that repealing the incentive could signal an unfriendly business climate. In 2024, House Bill 1192, which would have paused new exemption certificates, was vetoed.

Washington's legislative auditor reviewed a 2022 exemption for data centers in King, Pierce and Snohomish counties in a preliminary report in July 2026. Fewer than 10 businesses used it, all for refurbishing existing buildings, and no new urban data centers were built with it. Beneficiaries saved an estimated $42.4 million from 2023 to 2026. Property tax payments rose after the refurbishments. The auditor recommended letting the exemption expire, and the 2026 Legislature narrowed it to new data centers only.

Illinois publishes an annual ledger rather than an evaluation. DCEO's 2025 report lists 34 agreements with companies including Microsoft, Oracle, Equinix and Digital Realty, mostly in Elk Grove Village, Chicago and other suburbs. Those agreements commit $10.67 billion in investment and 731 new jobs, with estimated tax benefits of $666.6 million, calculated at 6.25 percent of committed investment. The report gives commitments rather than verified jobs. Governor JB Pritzker paused new agreements starting July 1, 2026, saying the state needed to learn whether incentives were driving development without regard to consumer costs.

Texas has not published a formal evaluation of its exemption. At a July 2026 Senate Finance Committee hearing, Comptroller officials said companies certify their own eligibility, and that six of the 20 projects that had entered the audit process were found noncompliant or withdrew. Asked how many jobs data centers create, chief revenue estimator Brad Reynolds said he did not know but that some projects struggle to reach 20. Lawmakers expected the exemption to cost about $14.6 million in the 2014–15 budget cycle. Current estimates for the coming two-year budget are $3.2 billion according to the Texas Tribune's reading of Comptroller figures, and about $3.3 billion according to Senate Finance chair Joan Huffman. Dan Diorio of the Data Center Coalition, an industry group, testified that the exemption encourages continuous reinvestment. Shannon Halbrook of the advocacy group Every Texan argued that the industry no longer needs the subsidy.

Construction jobs, permanent jobs and cost per job

Every evaluation that separates the two kinds of work finds that construction dominates. Industry representatives told JLARC that a typical 250,000-square-foot data center employs about 50 full-time workers, half of them contractors, while about 1,500 workers are on site at the peak of a 12- to 18-month build.

Cost per job depends on what is counted. JLARC's figure of 29 jobs per $1 million works out to about $34,000 per job each year, but that count includes construction, supplier and spending-driven jobs. Illinois's $666.6 million in estimated benefits divided by 731 committed jobs gives about $912,000. That calculation is this article's own, based on officials' numbers. The jobs in it are still commitments, and the benefits extend over many years. Georgia's report does not calculate a cost per job.

So the question of whether the jobs and revenue arrived has a partial answer. No state's evaluation found the exemption recovered its cost in state taxes. Large counties such as Loudoun collect substantial property taxes from data centers. Permanent, verified job counts mostly do not exist. Residents weighing a local deal can ask the questions the audits raise: what share of the project is assumed to depend on the break, who verifies the jobs and when, whether local property tax abatements are counted, and what the company must repay if it misses its targets.

What to watch

Texas: Huffman filed Senate Bill 293 on November 9, 2026, with a majority of senators as joint authors. It would repeal the exemptions in Tax Code Sections 151.359 and 151.3595 and deny pending applications. It is a proposal, not law, and the 90th Legislature convenes in January 2027.

Virginia: some legislators have said they will revisit the exemption when the General Assembly meets in January 2027.

Illinois: the pause on new agreements has been in effect since July 1, 2026. The governor asked lawmakers to act during the fall veto session, and these sources do not show the outcome. DCEO lists July 1, 2029, as the statutory cutoff for issuing certificates.

Washington and Georgia: Washington stops issuing new urban exemptions after July 1, 2028, and existing exemptions fully expire July 1, 2038. Georgia's exemption is set to end in 2033 after House Bill 1291 extended it in 2022.

Sources
  1. Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission (Virginia) — “Economic Development Incentives 2026”
  2. Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission (Virginia) — “Data Centers in Virginia (2024)”
  3. Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission (Virginia) — “Data Center and Manufacturing Incentives (2019)”
  4. Henrico Citizen / Virginia Mercury — “JLARC: Data center tax break accounts for 60% of Virginia's incentive spending”
  5. Georgia Department of Audits and Accounts / Carl Vinson Institute of Government — “Tax Incentive Evaluation: Georgia Data Center Sales & Use Tax Exemption (December 2025)”
  6. Washington Joint Legislative Audit and Review Committee — “2026 tax preference review: Data Centers in Urban Counties (preliminary report)”
  7. Illinois Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity — “Data Center Investment Program 2025 Annual Report”
  8. Office of the Governor of Illinois — “Gov. Pritzker Pauses New Data Center Tax Incentives”
  9. Texas Senate, Office of Sen. Joan Huffman — “Senator Joan Huffman Files Legislation to Repeal Data Center Sales Tax Exemptions”
  10. Texas Public Radio — “Texas lawmakers question billions in tax breaks for data centers”
  11. The Texas Tribune — “Texas losing a billion dollars a year on data center tax break”
  12. CBS Austin — “Could Democrats' election wins reshape Texas data center tax policy?”
  13. Rice University's Baker Institute for Public Policy — “How the Data Center Boom Affects the Texas Tax Base (working paper)”
  14. DatacenterDynamics — “American data center tax exemptions "out of control," according to report”